Sourcing Updated 31 May

Proteins — Seafood (Fish, Shellfish, Roe, Caviar)

Category 3 of 23 · Built 2026-04-20 · Last verified 2026-04-20 · UMAMI-15 Quality contract: PROCESS.md

Time-critical: Florida stone crab season closes May 15 (~3.5 weeks from this draft). If stone crab is on the menu this cycle, act before early May.

Miami-specific context: the kitchen has direct access to the strongest US domestic seafood market outside maybe San Diego and Boston. Stone crab, Florida lobster, hogfish, mutton snapper, grouper, wahoo, mahi — all caught within a 150-mile radius and landing at local markets within hours. That's a Tier-1 advantage most ventures can't claim. Tier 2 is still essential for Hawaiian sashimi grade, Maine shellfish, and Hudson Valley / New England specialty; Tier 3 is Japan-direct sushi-grade.

This file is longer than the meat + poultry files combined because seafood sourcing is the highest-stakes category (freshness window measured in hours; quality ladder ranges from "generic imported farmed" to "caught at dawn, on ice by 11 AM, on the cutting board by 6 PM"). Depth A entries earned.


FIN FISH — Finfish by Category

Sashimi-Grade Tuna (Bluefin, Bigeye, Yellowfin Toro)

Depth: A (confirmed in tuna-tartare-sherry-soy + crudo dishes; kanpachi-crudo adjacent)

What to know: "Sashimi-grade" is not a regulated term in the US — it's a reputational signal from a trusted supplier. Want: flash-frozen at -60°C (super-frozen) within hours of catch to neutralize parasites + preserve texture. Bluefin chu-toro ("middle-fatty") is the canonical crudo cut; o-toro is reserved for sushi dinners. Yellowfin is a budget alternative with less marbling. Never buy "sushi-grade" from a grocery-store counter without a fishmonger you trust by name.

🏬 TIER 1 — Easy Local (Miami)

🌐 TIER 2 — Excellent Online

👑 TIER 3 — Top Shelf

Cross-recipe: tuna-tartare-sherry-soy ✅, potential crudo starter variants.


Kanpachi / Hamachi / Kingfish

Depth: A (kanpachi-crudo is a core dish, MEMORY.md line 22 implied via Honolulu Fish Co order)

What to know: Kanpachi (Pacific amberjack) is the current Miami crudo darling — less fatty than hamachi, cleaner flavor, perfect for citrus-based dressings. Hamachi (yellowtail, Seriola quinqueradiata) is the sushi-counter default. Both are farmed in Hawaii at Kampachi Farms + on Kona side. Wild hamachi is rare outside Japan. Kingfish (hiramasa, Seriola lalandi) is Australian farmed, firmer than hamachi.

🏬 TIER 1 — Easy Local (Miami)

🌐 TIER 2 — Excellent Online

👑 TIER 3 — Top Shelf

Cross-recipe: kanpachi-crudo ✅ (home-cooked / corpus).


Salmon (Wild Alaskan Primary)

Depth: A (miso-salmon-sv in corpus; Copper River King is a May-June window event)

What to know: Farmed Atlantic salmon is everywhere; skip it for anything special. Wild Alaskan salmon has 5 species with distinct windows: Copper River King (late May-June, premium apex)Sockeye (June-August, richest color, strong flavor)Coho (July-Sept, milder)Chum/Keta (fall, budget)Pink (fall, canning-grade). King / Chinook can also be caught outside Copper River but Copper River King is the chef benchmark.

🏬 TIER 1 — Easy Local (Miami)

🌐 TIER 2 — Excellent Online

👑 TIER 3 — Top Shelf

Cross-recipe: miso-salmon-sv ✅.


Whitefish & Grouper Family (Snapper, Hogfish, Mutton, Grouper)

Depth: B (corpus-adjacent; whole-fish-kamado is the technique target, species varies by what's peak)

What to know: Florida's quiet superpower. Hogfish (Feb-Nov peak) — delicate, sweet, often #1 whitefish at Miami-area chefs. Mutton snapper (year-round, peak summer) — firm + sweet, holds well to grilling. Black grouper (offshore, year-round with restrictions) — forms the base of classic Bahamian/Florida grouper preparations. Yellowtail snapper (year-round) — the everyday grilling snapper; abundant. Avoid imported red snapper unless documented (90%+ mislabeled in US market — Oceana study).

🏬 TIER 1 — Easy Local (Miami)

🌐 TIER 2 — Excellent Online

👑 TIER 3 — Top Shelf

Cross-recipe: whole-fish-kamado ✅ (kamado-grilled whole hogfish or snapper is peak Miami summer).


Swordfish + Wahoo + Mahi (Mahi-Mahi / Dolphinfish)

Depth: B (grilling staples; whole-fish-kamado alt, kamado steak cuts)

What to know: All three are Miami-accessible pelagic species. Swordfish (year-round, peak summer) — firm, meaty, perfect for sous-vide + kamado + pan-sear. Wahoo (summer peak) — faster-swimming, leaner, delicate. Mahi (spring-summer peak in Florida) — sweet, mild, sustainable; almost always local.

🏬 TIER 1 — Easy Local

🌐 TIER 2 — Excellent Online

👑 TIER 3 — Top Shelf

Cross-recipe: swordfish-ceviche-bottarga ✅ (corpus), grilling preparations.


Mediterranean & European Imports (Branzino, Dorade, Turbot)

Depth: C (Spanish-identity and French-identity dishes; special-order)

What to know: These are the dishes where authenticity-of-fish matters. Branzino (Mediterranean sea bass, Dicentrarchus labrax) is the Roman/Greek/French grill standard. Dorade (royale, gilt-head bream) is the other Mediterranean whole-fish benchmark. Turbot is the French royalty fish — firm, rich, perfect for beurre blanc or asador-style wood fire. US availability is farmed + frozen-flown; the wild version is exponentially better but rare.

🏬 TIER 1 — Easy Local (Miami)

🌐 TIER 2 — Excellent Online

👑 TIER 3 — Top Shelf

Cross-recipe: turbot-on-kamado (planned, the Basque live-fire tradition tribute), branzino-roast.


SHELLFISH

Oysters (Live, In-Shell)

Depth: A (dinner-party staple; orders 50-100 count from Island Creek per event)

What to know: East Coast oysters = brinier, more mineral (Wellfleet, Beausoleil, Kumamoto hybrids). West Coast = sweeter, more melon/cucumber (Hama Hama, Kumamoto, Hood Canal). Always ask for "shipping date" — oysters are best within 7 days of shucking, 3 days of shipping. Serve over crushed ice with mignonette or lemon. Rule of thumb: 6-12 per person for a raw course depending on appetite.

🏬 TIER 1 — Easy Local

🌐 TIER 2 — Excellent Online

👑 TIER 3 — Top Shelf

Cross-recipe: Raw bar starter, baked-rockefeller preparations.


Stone Crab Claws (Florida — ⚠️ SEASON CLOSES MAY 15)

Depth: A (Miami-iconic; time-critical window)

What to know: Florida stone crab season: October 15 – May 15. Claws are the only harvested part (crab released alive, claw regenerates). Sizing: Medium (under 5 oz claw), Large (5-7 oz), Jumbo (7-8 oz), Colossal (8+ oz). Jumbo and Colossal are market scarce; peak claw size is end-of-season (April-May) when crabs are biggest. Serve cold with mustard sauce (Joe's Stone Crab recipe = Coleman's English mustard + mayo + heavy cream + Worcestershire + A1). This window closes in ~3.5 weeks.

🏬 TIER 1 — Easy Local (Miami)

🌐 TIER 2 — Excellent Online

👑 TIER 3 — Top Shelf

Cross-recipe: stone-crab-mustard-sauce starter / main depending on volume.


Florida Spiny Lobster (August – March)

Depth: B (Miami-season-specific; different season window than stone crab — NO overlap concerns)

What to know: Panulirus argus — the Caribbean/Florida spiny lobster. No claws (all meat in the tail). Season: August 6 – March 31. 2-day mini-season in late July for residents. Closed April-July. Tails from 5-12 oz typical; 1 lb tail is feast-quality. Grill split-tail with garlic butter is the peak preparation. Different tradition and flavor than Maine lobster — never substitute.

🏬 TIER 1 — Easy Local (Miami)

🌐 TIER 2 — Excellent Online

👑 TIER 3 — Top Shelf

Cross-recipe: lobster-rice (identified in MEMORY.md as a Briland-trip menu item; collaborative cooking favorite over carabineros per the lesson).


Maine Lobster (Live, 1.25-2 lb)

Depth: B (classical seafood boil + lobster rolls + Spanish rice-based dishes)

What to know: Homarus americanus — the North Atlantic clawed lobster. Female lobsters in roe season (summer) have richer flavor but most chefs reserve them for stock. Hard-shell lobsters > soft-shell for meat yield (soft-shell = post-molt, 20-30% less meat). Best season: Fall-Winter for hard-shells. Sizes: 1.25 lb (chicks), 1.5 lb (quarters), 2 lb (selects). 1.5-lb per person is generous.

🏬 TIER 1 — Easy Local

🌐 TIER 2 — Excellent Online

👑 TIER 3 — Top Shelf

Cross-recipe: lobster-rice (Spanish paella-adjacent), lobster roll, lobster thermidor.


Shrimp & Prawns (Gulf Whites, Key Wests, Carabineros, Live Spot)

Depth: A (corpus-critical — gambas-al-ajillo, aguachile-verde, deviled-eggs-bottarga-sv uses shrimp stock)

What to know: Domestic wild > farmed imported for flavor. Gulf White Shrimp (Texas-Louisiana coast) — sweet, firm, mid-size. Key West Pink / Royal Red (Florida) — deeper flavor than Gulf Whites. Carabineros (Spanish red giant prawns, Aristaeomorpha foliacea) — the pinnacle of a la plancha shrimp; deep red, sweet flesh, intense umami head-juice. Live spot prawns (Pacific/Alaska) — translucent when alive, rare, sashimi-quality.

🏬 TIER 1 — Easy Local

🌐 TIER 2 — Excellent Online

👑 TIER 3 — Top Shelf

Cross-recipe: gambas-al-ajillo ✅, aguachile-verde ✅.


Sea Urchin (Uni)

Depth: B (corpus-aspirational; the fearless-fusion register / the fearless-fusion register tier dish)

What to know: Uni = the gonads of sea urchin, orange-golden custard-like texture. California (Santa Barbara) = largest, richest, most widely available US domestic. Maine = smaller, cleaner/brinier. Hokkaido Bafun Uni = Japanese apex, tiny (walnut-sized), delicate. Quality metrics: firm structure (no soupy/broken lobes), bright orange/gold color, briny-sweet smell. Fresh whole urchins beat tray-packed uni for texture but shelf life is 2-3 days.

🏬 TIER 1 — Easy Local

🌐 TIER 2 — Excellent Online

👑 TIER 3 — Top Shelf

Cross-recipe: uni-shotgun course starter (planned, the fearless-fusion register-style), pasta al riccio.


ROE & CAVIAR

Caviar (Sturgeon)

Depth: A (dinner-party luxury course; referenced in MEMORY.md for Jesse's Briland arc)

What to know: Legal US caviar = farmed sturgeon (wild Caspian beluga is still CITES-restricted). Species ladder: Osetra / Oscietra (mid-gray to amber, nutty, 2nd-most-prized) → Siberian (mild, cleaner, baseline premium) → Sevruga (smaller pearls, intense) → Beluga hybrids (farmed beluga-crossed, largest pearls, buttery). Serve cold with bone/mother-of-pearl spoon (no metal), blini, creme fraiche, chopped egg + chive. 30-50g per person is generous.

🏬 TIER 1 — Easy Local (Miami)

🌐 TIER 2 — Excellent Online

👑 TIER 3 — Top Shelf

Cross-recipe: caviar starter course on blini; deviled-eggs-bottarga-sv has a luxury variant with Osetra topping.


Bottarga (Salted Cured Fish Roe)

Depth: A (corpus signature — deviled-eggs-bottarga-sv, swordfish-ceviche-bottarga)

What to know: Bottarga = salt-cured mullet or tuna roe, pressed and air-dried. Sardinian Gray Mullet bottarga = the Mediterranean gold standard, more delicate. Sicilian/Spanish Tuna bottarga = stronger, saltier, bigger form. Grated over pasta, thin-sliced over oils, or shaved into salads. Umami-concentrate at ~30x the flavor intensity of anchovies.

🏬 TIER 1 — Easy Local

🌐 TIER 2 — Excellent Online

👑 TIER 3 — Top Shelf

Cross-recipe: deviled-eggs-bottarga-sv ✅, swordfish-ceviche-bottarga ✅, grated over pasta.


Salmon Roe (Ikura) + Trout Roe

Depth: C (sushi-counter / canape-accent)

What to know: Ikura = salmon roe, bright orange, briny-sweet, larger pearl than most caviar. Trout roe = smaller, more delicate, less common. Both serve chilled on blini/toast/sushi.

🏬 TIER 1 — Easy Local

🌐 TIER 2 — Excellent Online

👑 TIER 3 — Top Shelf

Cross-recipe: garnish course.


Cross-Recipe Index (this category → corpus)

Recipe Primary species Recommended Tier 2 source
tuna-tartare-sherry-soy Sashimi-grade bluefin chu-toro or yellowfin 🏆 Honolulu Fish Co
kanpachi-crudo Hawaiian kanpachi sashimi cut 🏆 Honolulu Fish Co (owner-verified)
miso-salmon-sv Wild sockeye or Copper River King (seasonal May-June) 🏆 Vital Choice in-season · Whole Foods as fallback
whole-fish-kamado Hogfish / mutton snapper / black grouper (Miami local) Tier 1 Captain's Tavern or Casablanca
swordfish-ceviche-bottarga Swordfish loin + Sardinian bottarga Swordfish: Captain's Tavern / Honolulu Fish Co · Bottarga: 🏆 Regalis
gambas-al-ajillo Gulf white or Spanish-style red prawns Tier 1 Captain's Tavern · Tier 2 🏆 Regalis carabineros for upgrade
aguachile-verde Gulf/Key West raw shrimp Tier 1 Captain's Tavern / Casablanca
deviled-eggs-bottarga-sv Sardinian bottarga (+ Osetra luxury variant) Bottarga: 🏆 Regalis · Caviar: 🏆 Regalis
Lobster Rice (MEMORY line 143) Maine or Florida spiny lobster Maine: 🏆 Maine Lobster Now · Spiny: Tier 1 Key Largo Fisheries (Aug-Mar)
Oyster raw-bar starter East Coast oysters 🏆 Island Creek Oysters (owner-verified)
Stone crab claws starter/main Florida stone crab claws 🏆 Joe's Stone Crab (time-sensitive — closes May 15)
Caviar course (canape/blini) Osetra / Siberian 🏆 Regalis (owner-verified)
Uni-shotgun starter (planned) Santa Barbara or Hokkaido uni 🏆 Catalina Offshore or Regalis
Grouper preparations (planned) Black grouper / hogfish Captain's Tavern / The Fish House

Time-Critical Calendar (Miami + US Wild Seasons)

Species Season Peak Window Action
Florida stone crab Oct 15 – May 15 Apr-May (biggest claws) ⚠️ Closes in ~3.5 weeks. Book Joe's Colossal claws now if on roadmap.
Copper River King salmon Mid-May – Jun First 10 days of opener Pre-order Vital Choice in late April.
Florida spiny lobster Aug 6 – Mar 31 Aug opener, Nov-Dec peak Resident mini-season late July.
Maine lobster Year-round Fall-Winter hard-shell peak Wait for hard-shell season Sep-Feb.
Wild Pacific salmon (non-King) May – Oct Jun-Aug sockeye peak
Sardinian bottarga (new lot) Sep harvest Aged 3-6 mo, ready Dec-Feb
Spanish carabineros (Palamós) Year-round catch Oct-Dec deepest flavor Call Regalis Nov-Dec.
Wild Pacific spot prawns May – Aug Live + refreshed frequent May is peak live delivery.
Uni Santa Barbara Year-round with Jul-Aug closure Winter = richest roe Dec-Feb uni > summer uni.

Nearest-term action: book 2-3 lbs Jumbo/Colossal stone crab claws at Joe's Takeaway for a late-April or early-May event. Season-close window.


Verified Vendor Cross-Check (against MEMORY.md)

Vendor MEMORY.md line Status This file
Honolulu Fish Co 107 ✅ owner-ordered 🏆 Primary Tier 2 for sashimi tuna / kanpachi / Hawaiian species
Island Creek Oysters 106 ✅ owner-ordered 🏆 Primary Tier 2 for oysters
Regalis Foods 101 ✅ owner-verified 🏆 Primary Tier 2 for caviar, bottarga, carabineros, uni, turbot
The Golden Hog 108 ✅ verified Tier 1 caviar + bottarga + specialty
Chèvre Miami 101 ✅ verified Tier 1 caviar + bottarga
Captain's Tavern ⚪ curated (high-confidence based on press) Primary Tier 1 fishmonger
Casablanca Seafood ⚪ curated Tier 1 alternative
The Fish House ⚪ curated Tier 1 Key Largo drive-down
Vital Choice registry ⚪ curated (registry says "not tested") 🏆 Primary Tier 2 for Copper River King
Catalina Offshore registry ⚪ curated Tier 2 live spot prawns / uni
Browne Trading registry ⚪ curated Tier 2 alternate (Maine/New England)
Maine Lobster Now ⚪ curated 🏆 Tier 2 for Maine lobster
Joe's Stone Crab ⚪ curated (Miami iconic) 🏆 Tier 1 + 2 for stone crab
Key Largo Fisheries ⚪ curated Tier 1 for spiny lobster + local

Open questions


Notable gaps & future categories


Next category: 04-charcuterie.md — jamón ibérico, chorizo, sobrasada, salumi, pancetta. Cinco Jotas + La Tienda + Despaña dominate. The kitchen has deep identity here.

3/23 atlas files complete.

Umami · umami.pescao.io